The State University of New York at Buffalo and Sleep Solutions,
Inc. have joined together to fight two forms of life-threatening sleeping
disorders which impact millions. In Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA), the airway
relaxes and closes causing patients to stop breathing at least five times an
hour. Each non-breathing period is called an apnea. Over 18 million Americans
suffer from OSA, making it as prevalent as diabetes or asthma.
In the second form, Cheyne-Stokes Respiration (CSR-CSA), the
sleeping patient has cycles of slowing breath, then no breathing, followed by
increasingly rapid breathing. This breathing pattern is caused by the
body’s inability to regulate CO2 levels adequately. CSR affects 4.6 million
Americans.
Besides startling spouses, these sleeping disorders have serious
consequences. About one-third of hypertension patients have OSA and one half of
congestive heart failure cases have either OSA or CSR-CSA. By disrupting
sleeping patterns, altering the blood oxygen content and causing biochemical
alterations, OSA and CSR-CSA actually aggravate coronary conditions increasing
the mortality rates by 50%. OSA is also linked to diabetes, depression,
epilepsy and headaches.
In addition, the drowsiness and irritability caused by sleep
deprivation leads to family stress, personality changes and a six fold increase
in vehicular death. All told, undiagnosed OSA patients consume twice as many
healthcare resources and spend three times longer in the hospital as compared
to patients without OSA. The combination of high prevalence and serious health
risks makes obstructive sleep apnea as large a public health hazard as
cigarette smoking.
Despite the serious nature of these conditions, less than 5% of
the afflicted are diagnosed. This is partly due to the diagnostic procedure,
which requires an expensive and inconvenient overnight clinic stay. During the
stay, the patient sleeps while attached to dozens of chest and finger sensors
and is monitored by a camera. At the conclusion of the exam, hours of data are
manually inspected by the physician. Frequently, the stress of unfamiliar
surroundings alters the patient’s natural sleep patterns, masking the symptoms
of OSA. This can make extra nights of observation necessary. In addition, there
is a severe shortage of sleep disorder diagnostic centers and sleep technicians
(polysomnographers). OSA and CSR-CSA are treatable disorders, making the low
diagnostic rate particularly tragic.
Companies such as Sleep Solutions, Inc. have worked hard to
simplify sleep disorder diagnosis by allowing it to be performed at home.
First, pulse oximetry identification of OSA sufferers has been refined. Pulse
oximetry works on a simple principle. Most everyone is familiar with covering a
flashlight with their finger and making it “glow” red as if they were ET. Pulse
oximetry works the same way but quantifies the red color as a reflection of the
oxygen content of the blood in the finger. The oxygen content of the blood
decreases if the sleeper is not breathing during apnea. Second, pulse oximetry
devices have physically shrunk in size, making them portable. The units can now
be placed in the patient’s home, saving money, allowing patients to sleep in
the comfort of their own beds and providing more accurate diagnostic readings.
UB inventors Ali A. El-Solh, M.D., Brydon J. B. Grant, M.D. and
Jacek Dmochowski (now with the University of North Carolina at Charlotte) have
now supplied another advancement for at-home diagnosis. They created a unique
artificial intelligence software to use artificial neural networks to analyze
hours and hours of pulse oximetry data. Figure 1. A simple Artificial Neural
Network is shown above. These computer programs were originally designed to
mimic the human brain at a simple level. Each box represents a processing
element or “unit” analogous to a neuron. The input units process information
they receive and communicate the result to a hidden layer or layers of units.
Each of the results sent to the hidden layer is weighted. After processing the
results from the input layer, the hidden layer communicates the new results to
the output layer. The output layer then compares the generated results against
the experimental observation and uses a back-propagation algorithm to adjust
the weights assigned to the various inputs in order to optimize the final
result. In this way, the program can “learn” from its experiences.
Artificial neural networks (ANN), as the name implies, mimic
information processing as done by the brain (see figure 1). ANN programs
are trainable and are very good at sophisticated pattern recognition. The input
data consists of several measurements taken from the pulse oximetry readings.
Previous to this software, these measurements were analyzed separately to make
a diagnosis. This software is able to combine these measurements to create a
much more accurate diagnosis than previously possible. Further, it is able to
separately diagnosis OSA and CSR-CSA based solely on pulse oximetry data.
Previously, pulse oximetry was intended to screen only for OSA.
“Sleep Apnea is an important public health problem because it is
common and excessive daytime sleepiness can result in industrial and road
traffic accidents” stated Dr. Grant. “We became involved because it is a
disease that even expert physicians have difficulty in making the correct
diagnosis. Over the last decade, there have blossomed a number of new
statistical methods that have been designed to enhance predictive
properties. We have been exploring them in the hope of helping our colleagues
to make this diagnosis more accurately”.

| |
Input Layer| |
Hidden Layer| |
Output Layer |
In March, the University at Buffalo signed a licensing agreement
with Sleep Solutions, Inc. (SSI). Sleep Solutions is a privately owned company
based in Maryland. Their strong market presence and product line in area of
sleep apnea diagnosis as well as clinical-trial experience make them an ideal
partner to commercialize this technology. According to Michael J. Thomas,
President and CEO of Sleep Solutions, “This technology represents a
substantive advancement in the way OSA can be diagnosed. This new product
will broaden our portfolio of services of less expensive, more-patient-friendly
diagnostic testing products delivered directly to OSA patients in their
homes…SSI has contracted with many of the leading managed care organizations
throughout the U.S. and developed strong brand awareness of innovation,
cost-effectiveness and high-quality services with our core product, NovaSom™
QSG™.”
The average sleep lab receives $1,200 per sleep study; SSI’s goal
is to continue to drive down the cost of diagnostic testing for OSA and CSR by
at least 50% or more with these new technologies. SSI intends to apply to
the FDA for a 510k approval to market the University at Buffalo technology. If
the application process is successful, SSI will be able to market the new
technology to managed care organizations in early 2006.
With its NovaSom™ QSG™ At-Home Diagnostic System, Sleep
Solutions(tm), Inc. offers unassisted, at-home patient testing for obstructive
sleep apnea (OSA) through its Internet-Enabled NovaSom™ QSG™ Service. When
ordered by a physician, the NovaSom™ QSG™ System is shipped directly to the
patient’s home. The NovaSom™ QSG™ collects up to three nights of sleep data and
then it is returned to Sleep Solutions where the data are downloaded. A
comprehensive summary is sent to the physician for review and diagnosis. For
more information, contact Sleep Solutions at 877-753-3776 or visit
http://www.sleep-solutions.com
Contact information: University at Buffalo Office of
Science, Technology Transfer and Economic Outreach (STOR):
www.stor.buffalo.edu
Sleep Solutions, Inc.: www.sleep-solutions.com Michael
L. Fowler, Ph.D. is a Commercialization Manager for the University at Buffalo
Office of Science, Technology Transfer and Economic Outreach (STOR).
|